Search results

Yeah, there will always be 1 mm offside outcomes, don't have a problem with that and dont think there should be any discretion applied, just where the binary line is drawn.

Rules/laws can be modified. My view is that incidents such as this shouldn't be offside. It's nothing to do with preventing the greatest comeback ever, or goals that we have scored that have been ruled offside. I think the laws should be changed to reflect the fact that we now have VAR.

Because the defender was moving towards the goal, but the attacker still or moving slower?

Do you think that should be offside? Not whether it was or wasn't, but whether it should be.

You can't see the attacker and defender when the ball is played :shrug:

Maybe change the law so the lines are drawn at the furthest point from the goal for the attacker and the nearest for the defender?

It may be a technically correct decision. The issue, at least for me, is should this be the correct decision, i.e. should the current law/interpretation change so this wouldn't be technically offside? I think it should.